
Potions
Alchemy combat recipes plus Witch's Hollow cauldron effects. Early brew costs, Replace Skill vs Unlock, and loadout bands.
Potions overview
Alchemy combat recipes with ingredient and coin costs, plus Witch's Hollow cauldron effects. Read the live Alchemy or cauldron panel for unlock text.
How Alchemy fits the loop
Brews are consumable loadouts. Train, loot, and gear still carry the account; potions help the stages you already almost clear.
Training and wand Power still decide clear speed. Potions are the combat loadout on top, materials you might otherwise sell become the spells you cast each run. Some stronger recipes stay locked until later rebirths; the Alchemy panel shows that gate when it applies.
Brewing can also feed Collection Index milestones. If a chest will not move on materials alone, check whether the Index wants a new potion logged.
Replace Skill vs Unlock
Replace Skill swaps an equipped spell. Unlock is a separate Robux purchase for an extra slot - do not tap Unlock when you only meant to replace.
- Drink the potion you want equipped, then tap Replace Skill on a filled slot
- Unlock buys an extra slot with Robux, not a free swap
- Fill both free slots early; restock mats for the spells you keep casting
Early recipes
Ingredient lines and Alchemy coin costs for three early brews. Effect text and unlock gates stay on the live panel. Beta menus move.
| Potion | Ingredients | Alchemy cost |
|---|---|---|
| Fire Arrow Potion | Blueberry ×1 + Withered Mushroom ×1 | 9 Coins |
| Long-long Arms Potion | Golden Tooth ×1 + Goblin Finger ×1 | 19 Coins |
| Water Orb Potion | Goblin Finger ×1 + Dwarf Emblem ×1 | 29 Coins |
Witch's Hollow recipes
Six cauldron mixes from The Bell Tolls (Oct 25). Recipe Book holds 12 total — discover ingredients at the cauldron. Familiar's Feast and Witch's Brew can also appear in the Witch Shop. Candy Corn Food for pets is on Pets.
Witch's Hollow recipes sit in the Recipe Book (12 total after The Bell Tolls update on Oct 25). Experiment at the cauldron to unlock mixes. Ingredient lines stay on the live cauldron UI.
| Recipe | Effect | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Familiar's Feast | 2× Pet Coins | Can appear in the Witch Shop |
| Gilded Wing | +50% Gold | — |
| Ghostly Gumdrops | +250 Candy | — |
| Witch's Brew | 3× Training | Can appear in the Witch Shop |
| Full Moon Elixir | +1000% Luck | — |
| Lantern of Souls | +300% Luck & 2× Gold | — |
Hollow Night stages, Harrow's Return, and Witch Shop pet food notes live on Events and Pets.
Loadout bands
Useful defaults by stage band, not a frozen tier list. Match names on Alchemy before you dump materials into a brew you will not cast.
| When | Common picks | Note |
|---|---|---|
| About stages 1-4 | Fire Arrow + Water Orb | Common early multi-target pair once both recipes unlock. |
| About stages 5-12 | Dragon Breath with Thunder-thunder or Wood Thorn | Fan AoE plus multi/stun or damage/heal, confirm names on Alchemy. |
| Deeper / around Rebirth 10 | Radiant Sword pressure; Sheepy for single-target | Sheepy is a transform tool, not an AoE clear spell. |
Tip: some players drink a Lucky Potion before valuable runs for better rare loot odds, confirm the name and cost in Alchemy if you see that row.
Materials vs sell
Keep mats you need for the next brew; sell the rest for wand and armor coins.
Keep mats for the potions on your current loadout. Sell filler you will not brew soon so bag space stays free for Index-new drops. Event banners that advertise exclusive potions still need the live unlock path: see Events.
FAQ
Where do I brew potions?
Combat spells: open Alchemy in the hub. Witch's Hollow mixes: use the cauldron and Recipe Book. Match the recipe name, ingredients, cost, and any rebirth lock on that panel before you spend mats.
Are potions permanent upgrades?
No. They are consumable loadouts. Brew again when you run out of the spells you actually cast.
How do I swap an equipped spell?
Drink the potion you want, then choose Replace Skill on an existing slot. Unlock is a separate Robux purchase for an extra slot, do not tap Unlock when you only meant to replace.
Why are only three Alchemy recipes in the table?
Those three have confirmed ingredient lines and coin costs for the combat Alchemy sheet. Later names like Dragon Breath or Radiant Sword appear in loadout tips; full mats stay on the live Alchemy list.
What is Witch's Hollow?
A separate cauldron Recipe Book (12 recipes after The Bell Tolls on Oct 25). Six mixes are listed with effects above. Discover ingredients at the cauldron. Familiar's Feast and Witch's Brew can also show in the Witch Shop. Candy Corn Food for pet levels is on Pets.
Do event potions live here?
Limited banners can advertise exclusive potions. Check Events for the window, then read unlock text in Alchemy, the cauldron, or the event UI.